Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ancianita

(41,360 posts)
19. Big Nah. Back in 2021, SCOTUS made sure no emoluments charges would go anywhere. Ever.
Fri Apr 25, 2025, 02:00 PM
Apr 2025


https://www.scotusblog.com/2021/01/justices-vacate-rulings-on-trump-and-emoluments/

Emoluments cases
The Supreme Court vacated the lower courts decisions in a pair of cases involving allegations that, as president, Trump received benefits from the hotels and restaurants that he owns, in violation of two anti-corruption provisions of the Constitution known as the emoluments clauses. In one case, Trump v. Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit allowed a lawsuit by competitors in the hospitality industry to go forward, rejecting Trumps arguments that the competitors alleged injuries did not give them a legal right to sue. Represented by the Department of Justice, Trump filed a petition for review in September, asking the justices to hear oral argument and weigh in on whether the lawsuit could go forward. But by late December, when the petition was first distributed for the justices conference in early January, Trump had less than a month remaining in his term as president. In his reply brief, then-Acting Solicitor General Jeffrey Wall argued that the justices should wait to act on Trumps petition until after the inauguration and then vacate the 2nd Circuits ruling with instructions to dismiss the case as moot so that it would not serve as precedent for future cases a move known as Munsingwear vacatur.

Wall made a similar argument in Trump v. District of Columbia, in which the District and Maryland also alleged violations of the emoluments clauses. After a federal district court in Maryland allowed the case to go forward, Trump asked the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit for an order that would require the district court either to allow an immediate appeal or to dismiss the case, but the full 4th Circuit rejected that request. Trump then went to the Supreme Court in early September, but in his reply brief, filed in late December, Wall again recommended that the justices hold the petition until it becomes moot after the inauguration, and then grant certiorari and vacate under Munsingwear. The justices agreed to both of Walls recommendations on Monday morning, wiping away the appellate courts rulings in both cases and instructing the lower courts to dismiss the lawsuits as moot.


This SCOTUS gave the plaintiff Trump exactly what he wanted: that emoluments (above) and crimes (the immunity ruling) are not prosecutable when a Republican president is in office, especially THIS one.

Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Try to keep boonecreek Apr 2025 #1
What would dinner be? Cold McDonald's like he offered the championship football team? Rhiannon12866 Apr 2025 #2
Hamberders! boonecreek Apr 2025 #3
Here you go! Rhiannon12866 Apr 2025 #4
Don't forget the Imodium. boonecreek Apr 2025 #6
... Rhiannon12866 Apr 2025 #8
Mmmmmmmmmmm! Ray Bruns Apr 2025 #7
Homer would love it! Rhiannon12866 Apr 2025 #9
"$trump" Paladin Apr 2025 #5
True. Did you happen to notice that was aa dollar sign, not the letter "s"? niyad Apr 2025 #16
;-{) Goonch Apr 2025 #10
At least there's the authenticity of the flames of Hades behind him. (n/t) thesquanderer Apr 2025 #14
Photoshopped WmChris Apr 2025 #15
What's next? Jughead Apr 2025 #11
Shhhhhhh!!! Bo Zarts Apr 2025 #12
Just wear the SuperMan outfit and get it over with. NoMoreRepugs Apr 2025 #13
And she mocked his big hands. nt Hotler Apr 2025 #17
Hey, here comes the infamous Emoluments clause... ignored by repugs Justice matters. Apr 2025 #18
Big Nah. Back in 2021, SCOTUS made sure no emoluments charges would go anywhere. Ever. ancianita Apr 2025 #19
If they ever tried to make the US viewed as a banana republic... Justice matters. Apr 2025 #20
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Cable News Clips»'Who's that guy?' Rachel ...»Reply #19