Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Goonch

(4,435 posts)
17. You're right. AI confessed.....your point is well taken!
Fri Feb 13, 2026, 07:55 AM
19 hrs ago

AI did you fabricate the following quote? (my question)

"Same Time Next Year"
by Neal Shusterman.
It was famously published in the horror anthology Bruce Coville's Book of Spine Tinglers II
(1996).

.
"Elias punched the coordinates for
1924 into the brass console, desperate to see his grandmother one last time. He pulled the lever, expecting the smell of ozone and the sight of her garden; instead, he was met with an absolute, crushing silence .
When the flash faded, there was no garden. There was no air. Through the reinforced glass of his pod, Elias stared at the cold, indifferent glow of distant nebulae [3]. He hadn't accounted for galactic drift—while he had traveled back a century in time, the Earth had continued its relentless orbit around the Sun, and the Sun had continued its 500,000-mile-per-hour sprint around the Milky Way.

He had reached the right time, but the Earth was billions of miles away . He was a ghost in the vacuum, a man who had forgotten that in the universe, you can never go back to the same place twice"

Yes, parts of that quote appear to be
fabricated or paraphrased, though the story itself and its premise are real.

The short story "Same Time Next Year
" was indeed written by Neal Shusterman and first published in the 1993 collection Darkness Creeping. It was later anthologized in Bruce Coville's Book of Spine Tinglers II in 1997.

Verification of the Details
While the story exists and centers on the concept of "galactic drift" (traveling through time but staying in the same physical coordinates in space), the specific text you provided contains several inaccuracies:

Protagonist Name: The original story features a girl named Marla Nixbok (or Marla and a boy named Ford), not a man named Elias.

The Destination: Marla travels one year into the future (hence the title "Same Time Next Year&quot to escape her current generation, not to 1924 to see her grandmother.

The Text: While the ending description of floating in the vacuum because the Earth moved is the actual twist of Shusterman's story, the specific phrasing ("Elias punched the coordinates," "cold, indifferent glow of distant nebulae," etc.) does not match the published text. It appears to be a modern AI-generated "re-telling" or a hallucination of the specific prose.

In the original story, the protagonist realizes too late that the scientist who built the machine didn't account for the Earth's orbit, leading to her suffocating in the void of space.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

In one of the St. Mary's books Max and Eddy leave 18th century London in a hurry end up at the beginning of time. Srkdqltr Thursday #1
Got any more details? Goonch Thursday #2
Well, I read it ages ago, so it had to have been written as early as mid 20th century. raccoon Thursday #3
I mean details in the story Goonch Thursday #4
Sorry, I can't remember. THanks. raccoon Thursday #5
Not to beat a dead horse but: Was the main character male or female ..... Goonch Thursday #6
It was a man, a short story in a collection of short stories. raccoon Thursday #9
How about.... Goonch Thursday #11
Goonch, where did you get that quote? I've looked at a number of web pages about that story, and highplainsdem Thursday #12
That might've been it fits all the criteria. raccoon Thursday #13
Raccoon, that's the same title and author I gave you earlier, with links to 4 web pages about it. But the highplainsdem Thursday #14
You're right. It was. raccoon 22 hrs ago #16
Goonch, I really would appreciate your explaining where you got that quote. If it's from a website, highplainsdem Thursday #15
You're right. AI confessed.....your point is well taken! Goonch 19 hrs ago #17
Thank you, so much, for explaining what happened! I thought it could be a chatbot, but without highplainsdem 17 hrs ago #19
You may quote my posts in context if you also quote entirely my following inquiry to and responce from Google AI Goonch 14 hrs ago #20
I'm just going to summarize what happened, because with that long message you just posted from that highplainsdem 14 hrs ago #21
Had to ask ;-{) Goonch 13 hrs ago #23
Thanks! It can be hard to keep track of all the various AI and chatbot models. highplainsdem 13 hrs ago #24
Here's the link to my OP in General Discussion: highplainsdem 13 hrs ago #22
The Google AI provided this... marcopolo63 Thursday #7
Possibly Neal Shusterman's "Same Time Next Year" - though the time travel is to the future: highplainsdem Thursday #8
Thank you all! raccoon Thursday #10
highplainsdem is correct. AI fabricated Goonch 19 hrs ago #18
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Science Fiction»I remember an SF short st...»Reply #17