Gardening

Botany

(75,712 posts)

6. "So does anyone have a recommendation of a tree to plant in its stead?"

Sat Oct 3, 2020, 11:31 AM

Oct 2020

Sure. I am in the biz. Plant one that is native to your area. Do not plant one that is more than
1.5 to 2" in caliber any bigger is just a waste, they shock in many cases, and the smaller ones will
almost always by pass the bigger ones in a season or two.

Straight species and on their own root stock.

If you can plant 2 or 3 because they really do "talk to each other" through their roots.*

What part of America do you live in?

* The Hidden Life of Trees.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

40 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

So I thought my elm tree needed pruning and invited some estimates [View all] Baltimike Oct 2020 OP

I have been seeing a lovely tree everywhere lately. Cracklin Charlie Oct 2020 #1

Well you need to tell me where this is to be planted StClone Oct 2020 #2

I am in zone 7a, and am open to suggestions...maybe a flowering tree Baltimike Oct 2020 #4

I'll give a list here of workable choices StClone Oct 2020 #18

Where do you live ??? SamKnause Oct 2020 #3

Baltimike is from Baltimore, MD, zone 7a nt Baltimike Oct 2020 #5

Hybrid Poplar grows 5 to 8 feet per year. SamKnause Oct 2020 #10

"So does anyone have a recommendation of a tree to plant in its stead?" Botany Oct 2020 #6

I would be happy to plant two or three in Big Elm's stead. Baltimike Oct 2020 #8

Does the area get plenty of water? Botany Oct 2020 #9

It is a very wet area...humind for sure, but I have good drainage. nt Baltimike Oct 2020 #11

Go for a black gum then. Botany Oct 2020 #12

american cucumber tree? Baltimike Oct 2020 #15

Just looked it up but it* is native a little west of you. Botany Oct 2020 #17

How long after felling the elm tree do I have to wait to plant others? Baltimike Oct 2020 #19

As long as you have no roots in the way you can plant now Botany Oct 2020 #20

roots in the way? Like stump grinding removes them? Baltimike Oct 2020 #21

Stump grinding removes the stump Major Nikon Oct 2020 #22

Ok, I am serious, bc I really don't know Baltimike Oct 2020 #23

Don't worry too much about old roots-here is what you do StClone Oct 2020 #26

OMG, thank you for all of this Baltimike Oct 2020 #27

Friend No need to remove all the roots StClone Oct 2020 #32

I'm sure you could get a tree service to do it Major Nikon Oct 2020 #31

Hold up...should I be looking for a tree that grows in compacted soil? Baltimike Oct 2020 #35

Compacted soil will prevent water from reaching the roots Major Nikon Oct 2020 #36

Not a lot of people walk on it as I have a sidewlk leading to my porch Baltimike Oct 2020 #37

Crepe myrtle does well in poor soil Major Nikon Oct 2020 #38

I am looking for something a little bit bigger Baltimike Oct 2020 #39

I have an ash tree that is at least 30x30 Major Nikon Oct 2020 #40

I feel for you. CrispyQ Oct 2020 #7

I planted a white oak sapling I found growing on my property 20 years ago. OAITW r.2.0 Oct 2020 #14

When I hear White Oak I think StClone Oct 2020 #25

Interesting....had to look up this bird to see what it looked like. OAITW r.2.0 Oct 2020 #28

It's a small but stunning bird. StClone Oct 2020 #30

That is so sad. Look up, Linden Tree. wendyb-NC Oct 2020 #13

Yep. I really love this tree. I would save him if I could Baltimike Oct 2020 #16

Growing up in So. Maine in the 50/50s, we had beautiful American Elms and Horse Chestnut trees. OAITW r.2.0 Oct 2020 #29

If the catalpa grows in your area, you might consider one. The Velveteen Ocelot Oct 2020 #24

That's really beautiful. Baltimike Oct 2020 #33

I should add that I have cats that like to lounge in the yard. Baltimike Oct 2020 #34