Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

edhopper

(36,622 posts)

26. The problem with your analysis

Reply to JohnnyRingo (Original post)

Thu Sep 4, 2025, 09:13 PM

Thursday

Is you a basing it on the English translation. You must look at the ancient aremaic text to see what was intended.
It went through 3 or 4 languages before we got to "vain".

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

41 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

I've always had a beef with one of the Ten Commandments.. [View all] JohnnyRingo Thursday OP

"lords name in vain" rampartd Thursday #1

I get that. JohnnyRingo Thursday #4

Vanity doesn't come into it Easterncedar Thursday #14

Exactly. TomSlick Thursday #20

You might find this interesting TexLaProgressive Thursday #19

I see how that interpretation instructs how to use the Lord's name JohnnyRingo Friday #34

Long ago I read a series about the Dabney family TexLaProgressive Friday #36

I'm pretty sure swearing a "so help me god" oath ancianita Thursday #12

vowing "til death do us part " coul be stretched to false witness as well rampartd Thursday #16

Nope. Sin is intentional. Oaths like "Till death do us part" came later. ancianita Thursday #17

I like your thinking. Loryn Thursday #2

Amen Johnny, gab13by13 Thursday #3

Off topic, but here is a joke related to the comic you posted. John1956PA Thursday #5

Good one! ancianita Thursday #23

hahahaha JohnnyRingo Friday #29

I am not an expert state of stupid Thursday #6

Every time you say "I am". Blue Full Moon Thursday #7

I think it's ok to cuss Marthe48 Thursday #8

Man is the only animal to have found the ONE TRUE GOD ...............several of them. Mark Twain Ping Tung Thursday #9

According to Hebrew scripture Mossfern Friday #31

I think you proved Twain's point. There are millions of One True Gods available to pick. Ping Tung Friday #37

The Abrahamic and other religions are mostly Mossfern Friday #39

Yay! We agree! Why not? Indeed. Ping Tung Friday #40

That means I've always gotten that commandment wrong. Xavier Breath Thursday #10

Beeleeve BoRaGard Thursday #11

Is that where that came from? JohnnyRingo Friday #32

I think it is partly about those who pray for personal gain instead of for help to people in need of basics. . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Thursday #13

Absolutely Be The Light Thursday #15

Also professing faith for monetary or political reasons. surfered Thursday #18

Going back to the earliest version I stand a chance of translating, it's "in vanum" in the Latin Vulgate version muriel_volestrangler Thursday #21

Thanks, Muriel! summer_in_TX Friday #28

I'm the veteran of a profoundly religious upbringing who's morphed into an atheist. NNadir Thursday #22

I think the first one is weird. chouchou Thursday #24

Thanks Johnny Tatou Thursday #25

Welcome to DU LetMyPeopleVote Friday #38

The problem with your analysis edhopper Thursday #26

Oh. OK. JohnnyRingo Friday #33

Anybody that gets upset edhopper Friday #35

Catholic teaching on this would be much more dire DenaliDemocrat Thursday #27

Christ replaced the 10 commandments with 2 ... marble falls Friday #30

Ah, but for some Mossfern Friday #41