Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NNadir

(36,564 posts)
22. I'm the veteran of a profoundly religious upbringing who's morphed into an atheist.
Thu Sep 4, 2025, 01:56 PM
Sep 4

I never heard that interpretation of that "commandment" but it makes sense. As such, we can add it to the list of "commandments" that the orange pedophile in the White House violates.

Of course there is the issue, often ignored by fundies, of translation from one language to another. The Bible in English has been translated, a the act of translation is an act of change..

When my oldest son was born, to keep family peace, I had him baptized in the Episcopal church. This involved a number of Sundays where I had to make an appearance in church, something I didn't do much in my adult life other than for special events.

The Priest there, a young woman, offered a similarly novel interpretation of a scriptural injunction, "Spare the rod, spoil the child." Many people, including my father, interpreted this as an endorsement of corporal punishment, which is not to imply my father was abusive, but on the other hand I was subject to a smack or slap as was common in those times, something my sons never experienced. The Episcopal priest indicated that the authors of the Bible's Old Testament were in a culture of sheep herders (which says something about the breadth of their worldview) and that a "rod" was a stick used by shepherds not to beat sheep over the head, but rather to guide them on a path by gentle touches to their shoulders. This interpretation certainly didn't convert me back to Christianity but it did offer an alternative to what I see as a religion that talks peace but practices violence.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

"lords name in vain" rampartd Sep 4 #1
I get that. JohnnyRingo Sep 4 #4
Vanity doesn't come into it Easterncedar Sep 4 #14
Exactly. TomSlick Sep 4 #20
You might find this interesting TexLaProgressive Sep 4 #19
I see how that interpretation instructs how to use the Lord's name JohnnyRingo Sep 5 #34
Long ago I read a series about the Dabney family TexLaProgressive Sep 5 #36
I'm pretty sure swearing a "so help me god" oath ancianita Sep 4 #12
vowing "til death do us part " coul be stretched to false witness as well rampartd Sep 4 #16
Nope. Sin is intentional. Oaths like "Till death do us part" came later. ancianita Sep 4 #17
I like your thinking. Loryn Sep 4 #2
Amen Johnny, gab13by13 Sep 4 #3
Off topic, but here is a joke related to the comic you posted. John1956PA Sep 4 #5
Good one! ancianita Sep 4 #23
hahahaha JohnnyRingo Sep 5 #29
I am not an expert state of stupid Sep 4 #6
Every time you say "I am". Blue Full Moon Sep 4 #7
I think it's ok to cuss Marthe48 Sep 4 #8
Meh. You do you. Happy Hoosier Monday #42
Man is the only animal to have found the ONE TRUE GOD ...............several of them. Mark Twain Ping Tung Sep 4 #9
According to Hebrew scripture Mossfern Sep 5 #31
I think you proved Twain's point. There are millions of One True Gods available to pick. Ping Tung Sep 5 #37
The Abrahamic and other religions are mostly Mossfern Sep 5 #39
Yay! We agree! Why not? Indeed. Ping Tung Sep 5 #40
That means I've always gotten that commandment wrong. Xavier Breath Sep 4 #10
Beeleeve BoRaGard Sep 4 #11
Is that where that came from? JohnnyRingo Sep 5 #32
I think it is partly about those who pray for personal gain instead of for help to people in need of basics. . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Sep 4 #13
Absolutely Be The Light Sep 4 #15
Also professing faith for monetary or political reasons. surfered Sep 4 #18
Going back to the earliest version I stand a chance of translating, it's "in vanum" in the Latin Vulgate version muriel_volestrangler Sep 4 #21
Thanks, Muriel! summer_in_TX Sep 5 #28
I'm the veteran of a profoundly religious upbringing who's morphed into an atheist. NNadir Sep 4 #22
I think the first one is weird. chouchou Sep 4 #24
Thanks Johnny Tatou Sep 4 #25
Welcome to DU LetMyPeopleVote Sep 5 #38
The problem with your analysis edhopper Sep 4 #26
Oh. OK. JohnnyRingo Sep 5 #33
Anybody that gets upset edhopper Sep 5 #35
Catholic teaching on this would be much more dire DenaliDemocrat Sep 4 #27
Christ replaced the 10 commandments with 2 ... marble falls Sep 5 #30
Ah, but for some Mossfern Sep 5 #41
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I've always had a beef wi...»Reply #22