Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Ms. Toad

(37,604 posts)
12. So much wrong with that.
Sun May 25, 2025, 06:32 PM
May 2025

Even limiting the comment to type 2 diabetes -

The dietary recommendations by the largest American diabetic groups definition of low carb is several times the amount I can consume and keep my blood glucose in the normal range. So, absent keto cooking (too stringent for most diabetics to maintain), cooking lessons with solve it.

Weight is far less connected to diabetes than commonly assigned. In my family, diabetes is strongly hereditary (all descendants of my maternal grandfather my age or older have diabetes) relatively benign, not connected to cardiac risk, and present regardless of weight (descendants with lower than normal to obese BMI all have it). Personally, my blood glucose is more related to what I put on my mouth over the last 2 hours, than over time. I have had absolutely normal A1C levels - and abnormal ones - at all weights. I take 1000 grams of metformin a day. That's it. My levels aren't normal, but they are considered in control. I am teetering between overweight and obese.

In contrast, my spouse - skinny as a rail - has aggressive T2 diabetes. She was diagnosed with a blood glucose in the 300 range. She immediately went on 2000 mg of metformin, then Jardiance, replaced recently with Januvia, and when she still needed more, glimiperide. They upped her dose at her last visit.

Third - in my experience they are very reluctant to throw insulin at T2 diabetics. I expect to have to fight for it, if my A1C is ever elevated enough to need more than metformin. I won't take any of the medications my spouse is on - the pancreatic squeeze is not something I am willing to risk.

That said, they do need to spend far more time studying diabetes, so they aren't treating all T2 diabetes identically (both in terms of treatment and risks for comorbidities).

Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

He needs to educate himself. Withholding insulin would cause many, many, many immediate deaths. Vinca May 2025 #1
A bag of rat excrement like him... GiqueCee May 2025 #14
He obviously knows nothing about Type 1 diabetics--a bunch of skinny, sick kids Bayard May 2025 #29
And some adults who can acquire it as a result of endocrine system disorders. Vinca May 2025 #30
have a friend who's daughter was dx'd at 6 mos. mopinko May 2025 #31
I seem to recall TSF and his merry band of goons reversing the healthy school lunches put in place by Michelle Obama. sinkingfeeling May 2025 #2
Josh Johnson talks about that very thing in this video blogslug May 2025 #5
Yep. Anyone remember Sarah Palin and her Big Gulp... keep_left May 2025 #11
"Not just throwing insulin at people" means "in addition to insulin". TheRickles May 2025 #3
Yes, this is one of them. LuckyCharms May 2025 #7
Had the word order changed slightly rambler_american May 2025 #21
I still take the phrase to mean "throwing other things in addition to insulin". Whatever.... TheRickles May 2025 #25
It's a super insulting way of framing it no matter what the full statement was LearnedHand May 2025 #28
Aren't these the same people that mocked Michelle Obama over her concern with unhealthy school lunches? Solly Mack May 2025 #4
Of course, but it's Totally Different when a republicon does it. MLWR May 2025 #22
Type 1 here. Without insulin, I would last maybe 4-5 days. Then death. LuckyCharms May 2025 #6
Kill the non-whites malaise May 2025 #8
Does this doofus know anything about the discovery of insulin.........let me remind this idiot............ turbinetree May 2025 #9
Really? peggysue2 May 2025 #10
It's old-time hee-haw American Calvinism once again. keep_left May 2025 #13
The Repugs just won't come out and say it. Delmette2.0 May 2025 #26
So much wrong with that. Ms. Toad May 2025 #12
My late mother had Type 2 diabetes jmowreader May 2025 #17
Times are different now. Ms. Toad May 2025 #18
When the nice black woman focused on school lunches, you called her a communist JT45242 May 2025 #15
Suffering Jesus. How stupid can one person be and still breathe? TomSlick May 2025 #16
I'll bet nobody will ever be capable of explaining to him Warpy May 2025 #19
"Throwing insulin" is just another iteration. . . Collimator May 2025 #20
Type 1 is what my great niece LittleGirl May 2025 #23
I checked Marty Makary's resume. It is very impressive and he is obviously highly regarded by his peers. flashman13 May 2025 #24
Prediabetes could be treated with cooking classes and access to healthier food NickB79 May 2025 #27
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Trump FDA commissioner co...»Reply #12