The DC assassin is not a religious nutcase. Not a maladjusted outcast. Not a low-down vigilante.

[noor]

138. "Responding to Tragedy with Reason, Not Generalization"

I understand your deep concern about the implications of antisemitism and the potential dangers it poses to Jewish communities. Antisemitism in any form is unacceptable and must be confronted without hesitation.

However, I think it's important to avoid painting entire movements or groups with a broad brush based on the actions of an individual. Supporting Palestinian rights or criticizing the policies of the Israeli government is not inherently antisemitic, and many Jewish individuals and organizations around the world make similar critiques out of a deep commitment to justice and human rights.

Equating calls for Palestinian freedom with antisemitism risks silencing legitimate political discourse and alienates allies in the fight against real hate. The line between speech and violence is critical, and conflating the two can lead us down a path of fear-driven reaction instead of thoughtful resolution.

We should absolutely condemn violence and hate, but we should do so with clarity and precision—not by labeling entire communities or political positions as enemies. Doing otherwise risks fueling division rather than fostering safety and understanding.

Let’s be vigilant, but also fair. Justice and security for one group should not come at the expense of justice and dignity for another.