Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
32 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Still a Mother, always a Mother. Please save a special thought for those of us who have lost a child. This (Original Post) Raven May 11 OP
You are in my thoughts, Raven... hlthe2b May 11 #1
One of my friends lost her son last wk Marthe48 May 11 #2
💐💔💐 blm May 11 #3
THANK you. Duppers May 11 #4
That is a tough one. I am so sorry and it doesn't matter how many years ago. LoisB May 11 #16
Thinking of you and Will today. quaint May 11 #5
So hard to imagine anything worse than burying your child. OAITW r.2.0 May 11 #6
Bless you Raven. redwitch May 11 #7
Sending special warm love to you and others. MuseRider May 11 #8
Sending love Diamond_Dog May 11 #9
Raven 💚 Clouds Passing May 11 #10
I had two sons. PoindexterOglethorpe May 11 #11
.... Clouds Passing May 11 #12
I believe that too. I am sorry. LoisB May 11 #18
Answering others. Maybe it depends on what you think of them first glace, how you feel that day etc electric_blue68 May 12 #23
Know that I share your pain. True Blue American May 12 #27
Some years after my brother, younger by 3 years and my only sibling, died way too young... 3catwoman3 May 12 #29
Thank you for your post. PoindexterOglethorpe May 13 #31
I have a friend whose son took his own life mnhtnbb May 13 #30
Thinking of you today, Raven. calimary May 11 #13
Sending kind thoughts and hugs. MLAA May 11 #14
Yes markie May 11 #15
Peace to all the mothers (and fathers) who have lost a child. There is no greater loss. LoisB May 11 #17
I feel their pain. kacekwl May 11 #19
You are not alone MorbidButterflyTat May 11 #20
I am so sorry Raven JMCKUSICK May 11 #21
I knew there was a reason soldierant May 11 #22
Strength to you all electric_blue68 May 12 #24
I think I understand your pain. Ptah May 12 #25
Yes, it is True Blue American May 12 #26
My prayer is for anyone who has lost a child from their lives. marble falls May 12 #28
❤️ underpants May 14 #32

Marthe48

(20,683 posts)
2. One of my friends lost her son last wk
Sun May 11, 2025, 04:39 PM
May 11

I hadn't met him. Friend and I reconnected on fb 40 yrs after h.s. She is a nice person and I feel terrible for her.

MuseRider

(34,673 posts)
8. Sending special warm love to you and others.
Sun May 11, 2025, 06:33 PM
May 11

I cannot even begin to imagine if I had lost either of my sons. It is too painful to even imagine.

Will was a hard loss for all of us here but especially for you. Not even close. There can't be much else worse than that. I hope at least the hard edge of that pain can ease a bit. Warm thoughts and love to you and all who suffer this day.

PoindexterOglethorpe

(27,882 posts)
11. I had two sons.
Sun May 11, 2025, 07:08 PM
May 11

One took his life in 2017.

I never know quite what to say when people ask me if I have children. Do I say I had two? Do I just say I have one?

As awful as it was to lose him, I have several thought here. One is that I'm grateful to still have one son. Losing your only, or losing all of them would be truly awful.

Another thought: I honestly think it would be much worse to lose a child to a disease, some terrible accident, worse yet in some mass shooting. He made a choice I wish he had not made, but it was his choice.

It helps me that I firmly believe that our souls survive bodily death, and that I will see him again.

True Blue American

(18,534 posts)
27. Know that I share your pain.
Mon May 12, 2025, 09:53 PM
May 12

And at times, even worse is a Son thinking he has to fill 2 places. It is hard for them,too. I finally just started saying,” I had 2,” but then come the questions.

3catwoman3

(26,725 posts)
29. Some years after my brother, younger by 3 years and my only sibling, died way too young...
Mon May 12, 2025, 10:40 PM
May 12

...at only 23, in a winter time scuba diving excursion that ended badly, I asked my mother what she would say when people asked her if she had any children. Her answer - I have a daughter. I had a son.

This was way back in 1978. When my brother died, I was newly stationed at Yokota Air Base in Japan, with the Air Force nurse corps. I'd been there barely 3 weeks, so knew very few people. Went back to the States for the funeral, and then back to Japan. When you are new to a military base/assignment, you are always meeting lots of people, and always asked about where you are from, and about your family.

A sure-fire way to bring conversation to a screeching halt is to have to announce, when asked if you have any brothers or sisters, that your sibling just died. Everyone apologizes in horror for unknowingly bringing up such a sad topic, and I'd end up trying to make them feel better for their innocent error. It was agonizing. Sometimes, when asked if I had any siblings, I would just say "No" if I didn't feel like dealing with it at that moment.

I hope it is OK if I express my admiration for the acceptance you seem to have found with your son's choice. And I hope the son you still have with you is OK.

One additional thought. Awful as the sudden and unexpected loss of my brother was, if it had to be, I'm grateful that I did not have to watch him waste away from some dreadful illness.

PoindexterOglethorpe

(27,882 posts)
31. Thank you for your post.
Tue May 13, 2025, 11:07 PM
May 13

I do know how easy it can be to bring a conversation to a screeching halt, as you put it, by mentioning a dead child.

The thing is, many of us have lost a child. I'm a woman, despite my screen name, and have two good women friends, one lost a son shortly after birth, the other lost hers when he was about twenty.

When my son died, one of my first thoughts was that all his friends would forget him soon. That has not happened. His friends still post on his FB page, and that means a lot to me. People constantly trash FB, but they are wrong. Okay, so you're not a fan, I get it. But were it not for FB, it would have literally been years for his friends/acquaintances learn of his death. About two, maybe three years after he died, someone came to his page and was saddened to learn of his death. But at least he found out.

My living son, whom I talk about here as My Son The Astronomer, is finishing up a PhD in astronomy. He's a bit on the spectrum, so he's not one to talk about feelings, or emotions, and so I'm not entirely certain how he's dealt with his brother's death.

mnhtnbb

(32,527 posts)
30. I have a friend whose son took his own life
Tue May 13, 2025, 06:07 AM
May 13

several years ago, too. She is quite open about it, and doesn't hesitate to share memories of him on his birthday or the day he chose to end his life.
She and I also share having lost an infant: mine to premature stillbirth and hers just a few days after he was born. That is somewhat more tricky for me, as my daughter never drew breath. But she remembers her infant son, too. She says she had three children, but only her daughter is still living. I say I had three children, but only my two sons are alive.

I'm sorry for the loss of your son.

calimary

(86,421 posts)
13. Thinking of you today, Raven.
Sun May 11, 2025, 07:19 PM
May 11

Please know you’re not alone even while you may feel that way. As one wise DUer once said: “someone’s always here.”

LoisB

(10,576 posts)
17. Peace to all the mothers (and fathers) who have lost a child. There is no greater loss.
Sun May 11, 2025, 07:38 PM
May 11

kacekwl

(8,291 posts)
19. I feel their pain.
Sun May 11, 2025, 10:04 PM
May 11

My daughter lost a child shortly after birth. Nothing has ever been so difficult and yet so sweet as holding her passed child in my arms.

JMCKUSICK

(2,477 posts)
21. I am so sorry Raven
Sun May 11, 2025, 10:42 PM
May 11

And that only adds to my admiration for your courage and strength in standing up for so many "Forgotten Mothers".
Thank you!

soldierant

(8,557 posts)
22. I knew there was a reason
Sun May 11, 2025, 10:44 PM
May 11

I saved the email this came in ... hope it helps.

https://johnpavlovitz.substack.com/p/for-those-who-hurt-on-mothers-day

I never had children, never wanted to. What I had was endometriosis and the only thing connected with reproduction I ever wanted was menopause. But I generally agree with almost everything John has to say. And 100% with this essay. So it's from me too.

electric_blue68

(21,493 posts)
24. Strength to you all
Mon May 12, 2025, 09:28 PM
May 12

I have no memory...

My non-fraternal premature twin died a few hours after her birth (she was 2nd). Found out after a relevant Dr Kildare we were watching when I was ?11 yrs old.
Not aware enough to ask her how they took it.

Ptah

(33,753 posts)
25. I think I understand your pain.
Mon May 12, 2025, 09:39 PM
May 12

My mother lost a son and a grandson before she passed.

True Blue American

(18,534 posts)
26. Yes, it is
Mon May 12, 2025, 09:47 PM
May 12

And the hurt never fades. I know. Try to appreciate what we still have.
My whole family has Covid. So Mothers Day will be another time.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Still a Mother, always a ...