Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

babylonsister

(172,100 posts)
Sat May 17, 2025, 06:49 AM May 17

Trump Allows Sale of Device to Transform Firearms


https://politicalwire.com/2025/05/16/trump-allows-sale-of-device-to-transform-firearms/

Trump Allows Sale of Device to Transform Firearms
May 16, 2025 at 9:00 pm EDT By Taegan Goddard


The Trump administration has decided to permit the sale of devices that enable standard firearms to fire like machine guns, a move that one person familiar with the matter said was “by far the most dangerous thing this administration has done” on gun policy, NBC News reports.

65 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Trump Allows Sale of Device to Transform Firearms (Original Post) babylonsister May 17 OP
Trump loves killing Americans. Irish_Dem May 17 #1
He just loves killing -- especially if his victims are powerless. LastLiberal in PalmSprings May 17 #13
Wonderful. As if there wasn't enough to worry about already. Vinca May 17 #2
So all this talk about being afraid of assassination was just BS Walleye May 17 #3
Bad assumption. paleotn May 17 #6
Throwing another bone to his bloodthirsty MAGA gun worshippers, to distract them from his many failures. sop May 17 #4
The U.S. is already dead. Layzeebeaver May 17 #5
The awful sounds we hear...are the mass shooting victims spinning in their graves. FailureToCommunicate May 17 #7
re: reset triggers TnDem May 17 #8
Yeah, we need somebody to gunsplain this. Honestly, don't care about people who want more guns Walleye May 17 #9
re: understanding TnDem May 17 #21
It's a good logic, but no matter of logic is going to convince these people. They're nuts. Walleye May 17 #25
re: understanding TnDem May 17 #30
Almost everyone who wants a gun should have one. But they should remember what their purpose is Walleye May 17 #31
Hey, if we have to know chapter and verse on firearms to convince Aristus May 17 #33
I was ForgedCrank May 17 #22
Why? k_buddy762 May 20 #63
Not a machine gun just lets the shooter pull the trigger faster. 2MuchNoise May 17 #23
re: "pull trigger faster" TnDem May 17 #24
Yeah I'm not losing any sleep over forced reset trigger devices Shermann May 17 #27
I'm pretty knowledgeable about firearms, and you're dead wrong NickB79 May 17 #47
re: the law TnDem May 17 #50
Just how much... JPK May 17 #55
This is a video of someone using one of these jmowreader May 17 #49
This is correct k_buddy762 May 17 #53
Someone's gonna get to him using a bump stock. BradBo May 17 #10
Gun nutz Dave Id May 17 #11
Mexico will love this! RainCaster May 17 #12
Another step in his kill Americans tour paid for by Pooty and Eloon. lark May 17 #14
He's just trying to restore his losses among the MAGAt followers. Wonder Why May 17 #15
Crazy motherfuckers. spanone May 17 #16
I don't care anymore. * 617Blue May 17 #17
Then it should be called a "Trumper Conversion". JohnnyRingo May 17 #18
Hope Supressorors Lullybuy May 17 #19
Agreed. k_buddy762 May 17 #54
They want more shootings Beck23 May 17 #20
'Make my Glock go full auto': How criminals turn standard firearms into illegal machine guns Swede May 17 #26
re: "full auto" TnDem May 17 #29
That's for the militias stollen May 17 #28
Exactly what I thought when I read this, stollen peggysue2 May 17 #34
We will have "big beautiful guns!" yellowcanine May 17 #32
A man came up to me, a big man, a big strong man, a big, strong man who knows guns... 2MuchNoise May 17 #37
So, like, are bump stocks now passé? Brother Buzz May 17 #35
re: bump stocks TnDem May 17 #41
One sentence in the article isn't true Kaleva May 17 #36
re: machine guns TnDem May 17 #40
With the proper license, those restrictions don't apply Kaleva May 17 #43
Uh, not exactly TnDem May 17 #44
What you are saying doesn't refute what I said Kaleva May 17 #45
Uh, yes it does because they aren't transferable TnDem May 17 #46
Five, six, or even seven figures k_buddy762 May 17 #56
You are fixated on the gun being transferable Kaleva May 18 #58
re: Class 3 law TnDem May 18 #59
My father didn't own the small dairy farm he operated Kaleva May 19 #60
No, you don't TnDem May 19 #61
But you admit that my father could have owned them? Kaleva May 20 #62
Can you admit you are wrong? TnDem May 20 #65
Will the devices have "For Aryans Only" restrictions on them? Ping Tung May 17 #38
3D printed "glock switches" k_buddy762 May 20 #64
I would not mind one bit if this becomes one of his biggest ironies Nictuku May 17 #39
I agree Greywing May 17 #42
Rule of thumb: B.See May 17 #48
The Fox News MAGA conspiracy theory GOP wants us all dead. Initech May 17 #51
This is what the Proud Boys standing by have been waiting for. Kid Berwyn May 17 #52
Trump says bump stocks make the gun into a machine gun. Will ban them? Norrrm May 18 #57
13. He just loves killing -- especially if his victims are powerless.
Sat May 17, 2025, 09:01 AM
May 17

His attack on USAIDS (Musk was acting as his agent) has killed people through denying life-saving drugs. He also denied them of food they needed to feed their children.

He appointed RFK Jr., a rabid anti-vax advocate, to oversee the health system. The result has been 1,000 deaths from measles -- a disease which had been eradicated through a program of mandatory vaccinations.

Trump will be seen as not only the dumbest and most corrupt president this country has ever had, but also the cruelest.

Walleye

(40,690 posts)
3. So all this talk about being afraid of assassination was just BS
Sat May 17, 2025, 07:00 AM
May 17

Maga always assumes that their side will have the guns

sop

(14,427 posts)
4. Throwing another bone to his bloodthirsty MAGA gun worshippers, to distract them from his many failures.
Sat May 17, 2025, 07:11 AM
May 17

Trump would have his followers believe MS-13 is more of a threat to America than angry, depressed incels carrying AR-15s with bump stocks.

TnDem

(854 posts)
8. re: reset triggers
Sat May 17, 2025, 08:34 AM
May 17

The comments on this article are "exhibit A" of the ignorance of firearms and why we continually lose elections.

The reset trigger does NOTHING like the article states, and show an utter lack of mechanical knowledge of something they think is scary, but do not understand..

The reset trigger merely resets on the pull and release of the trigger instead of just the "pull"....It is NOT a machinegun, it doesn't ACT like a machinegun, and ultimately would have been lost at the SCOTUS level, simply because the trigger itself is not regulated under GCA 68 or NFA 34/37 which regulate machineguns.

These comments are why Carolyn McCarthy's 25 year old comments about "the shoulder thing that goes up" have become a right wing meme...They were given by her on MSNBC when Carlson was still on that network when asked what her legislation actually meant and she couldn't even describe it.

Walleye

(40,690 posts)
9. Yeah, we need somebody to gunsplain this. Honestly, don't care about people who want more guns
Sat May 17, 2025, 08:46 AM
May 17

And if only we understood guns we’d win elections? I don’t think so. do you think these guys are going to vote for us if we pander to them?

TnDem

(854 posts)
21. re: understanding
Sat May 17, 2025, 09:40 AM
May 17

I can tell you this....it is very difficult to win any argument or discussion if you can't even understand explain the basic facts to the gal on the street in Knoxville that wants to actually know what all of this means.

They damn sure won't vote for us if we can't explain how and what legislation means specifically and not emotionally.

Walleye

(40,690 posts)
25. It's a good logic, but no matter of logic is going to convince these people. They're nuts.
Sat May 17, 2025, 09:58 AM
May 17

And I do have respect for people have technical knowledge of guns. I just don’t think it should be our religion. I personally have never desired a gun or needed one. Never has the thought crossed my mind if I only had a gun right now. To me it’s just providing the bad guys with weapons.

TnDem

(854 posts)
30. re: understanding
Sat May 17, 2025, 10:52 AM
May 17

I suggest that you go back and re-read your own response here. You will see authoritarian emotion without a need to understand anything you dislike.

Understanding firearms is not a "religion", nor do people that do attempt to understand these things are not "nuts" as you say...It is no different than understanding Medicaid, immigration or any other issue.

Just because you decide that you decide that you don't want or need a firearm doesn't mean that possible Democratic voters in rural and even urban areas share that same hand-wringing desire to be willingly ignorant.

Walleye

(40,690 posts)
31. Almost everyone who wants a gun should have one. But they should remember what their purpose is
Sat May 17, 2025, 10:58 AM
May 17

I don’t wanna be ignorant about guns. I just don’t wanna be shot by some stray bullet or mass shooter who doesn’t know how to handle them. We have way too many guns in this country. And things are a lot different in city where bullets can travel very far and hit a lot of people. If I lived out in the country by the woods or something, I would want some sort of firearm, but just for critters not for people. I do appreciate the dialogue, and I know people who collect guns. It’s not such a bad hobby.

Aristus

(70,046 posts)
33. Hey, if we have to know chapter and verse on firearms to convince
Sat May 17, 2025, 11:22 AM
May 17

the Trumpanzees, then they should have to explain that they understand what tariffs are, and how they hurt the economy, before they go voting for some dipshit who doesn’t understand tariffs.

BTW, it’s been thirty years since I so much as touched an M-16 rifle. But I’m confident that I could still field strip it blindfolded in less than thirty seconds. Opposition to private ownership of firearms doesn’t necessarily stem from ignorance of firearms.

ForgedCrank

(2,637 posts)
22. I was
Sat May 17, 2025, 09:43 AM
May 17

afraid to be the one to say it, thanks for injecting facts into this.
FRT does not convert a firearm to a "machine gun" in any way, and it does not make it "full auto".
We will never win on merit if we don't start being openly honest about this stuff.

2MuchNoise

(144 posts)
23. Not a machine gun just lets the shooter pull the trigger faster.
Sat May 17, 2025, 09:46 AM
May 17

Phew! I feel sooo much better about it now. NOT!

TnDem

(854 posts)
24. re: "pull trigger faster"
Sat May 17, 2025, 09:52 AM
May 17

Again, an emotional argument.

Google or YouTube "shoe string" bump stock and you will see how triggers are pulled faster with a piece of string...It means zilch except shittier aim and waste of ammunition....and time arguing against it.

This is why people with real knowledge of mechanics roll our eyes at this shit.

Shermann

(8,937 posts)
27. Yeah I'm not losing any sleep over forced reset trigger devices
Sat May 17, 2025, 10:19 AM
May 17

Most gun violence is one armed individual versus one unarmed individual. So armed with the most basic firearms out there it is still like shooting fish in a barrel. These devices can increase the rate of fire slightly which might change the calculus on a battlefield. But militaries will have real automatic fire weapons so there won't even be much interest there. In the hands of an average civilian making poor purchasing decisions at the gun show these will mostly likely just convert their weapons into jam-o-matics.

NickB79

(19,921 posts)
47. I'm pretty knowledgeable about firearms, and you're dead wrong
Sat May 17, 2025, 10:39 PM
May 17

You are describing a binary trigger. Rare Breed sells a forced reset trigger, a different type of trigger design. This is a FRT in action, by none other than Garand Thumb, one of the best shooters posting on YouTube. Watch his finger on that trigger; it doesn't move after each shot.

In performance it's no different than a full auto.

?si=EEhmvqMcBRxROyZc

TnDem

(854 posts)
50. re: the law
Sat May 17, 2025, 11:21 PM
May 17

The interpretation of the law states that both BT and FRT's are legal....The FRT's require a very finicky consistent pressure to make them work as shown...Binary triggers automatically double your rate of fire without a learning curve....I am aware of Garand Thumb as well as the differences between the two triggers.

Both FRT's and bumpstocks operate on a slightly similar philosophy as it takes a lot of finesse to make them work consistently as shown....BT's don't need much of a lesson.

Since everything is specific, both BT and FRT's operate consistent with federal interpretation of statute..."A single function of the trigger" being the key words...On FRT, the reset itself pushes the trigger very slightly forward after the previous shot. It is still a "single function", just like a BT....But the shooter still has to use to make the firearm actually fire each time.

JPK

(782 posts)
55. Just how much...
Sat May 17, 2025, 11:46 PM
May 17

Manly gear can this man child wear? It's like he hit a army surplus store and stocked up on molle bags and mag pouches. The headset with mic is a nice touch. It completes the ensemble.

jmowreader

(52,337 posts)
49. This is a video of someone using one of these
Sat May 17, 2025, 11:05 PM
May 17


The firer in this video is the man who invented the forced reset trigger, Lawrence DeMonico, President of Rare Breed Triggers. Having been in the Army and having fired the M16A1 rifle in AUTO mode, the M16A2 rifle in BURST mode and the M60 machine gun I can safely say I know what a machine gun looks like.

And that, my friend, is a machine gun.

k_buddy762

(324 posts)
53. This is correct
Sat May 17, 2025, 11:33 PM
May 17

More fear mongering for a mechanical device that operates nothing like the article claims.

Dave Id

(109 posts)
11. Gun nutz
Sat May 17, 2025, 08:51 AM
May 17

Will gun nutz line up at gun dealers at midnight like gamers waiting at Best Buy and Walmart for a new game system?

RainCaster

(12,878 posts)
12. Mexico will love this!
Sat May 17, 2025, 08:52 AM
May 17

Their suit against the US for providing so many automatic arms to the drug cartels just got a boost. I hope they win bigly.

lark

(25,055 posts)
14. Another step in his kill Americans tour paid for by Pooty and Eloon.
Sat May 17, 2025, 09:02 AM
May 17

Everything he does is for his personal benefit or to hurt others - those are his only modes. He hates everyone in the working class, even his own voters and would kill us all for pennies if he gets the choice.

JohnnyRingo

(19,946 posts)
18. Then it should be called a "Trumper Conversion".
Sat May 17, 2025, 09:20 AM
May 17

Then whenever there's a lunatic mass shooting his name will be in the news.

TnDem

(854 posts)
29. re: "full auto"
Sat May 17, 2025, 10:30 AM
May 17

Great emotional argument, except:

1) A forced reset trigger is not full auto
2) Modifying a semi-auto to a full-auto is a Federal Felony
3) This FRT is for a rifle and not a Glock.

Of course, factual specifics doesn't make for good emotional fist-bumping.

peggysue2

(11,877 posts)
34. Exactly what I thought when I read this, stollen
Sat May 17, 2025, 11:26 AM
May 17

When push comes to shove, Agent Orange wants his minions to have every advantage.

2MuchNoise

(144 posts)
37. A man came up to me, a big man, a big strong man, a big, strong man who knows guns...
Sat May 17, 2025, 12:31 PM
May 17

a big, strong man who knows guns, he had tears in his eyes and he said sir, sir, please sir I want to tell you how I feel about reset triggers
I said sorry, sorry big, strong man I can't listen to you...you're too emotional.

TnDem

(854 posts)
41. re: bump stocks
Sat May 17, 2025, 01:31 PM
May 17

Bump stocks are already stupid and were always "passe".

You can do the same thing with a shoestring...YouTube videos abound with shoestring bumpstocks.

Kaleva

(39,414 posts)
36. One sentence in the article isn't true
Sat May 17, 2025, 11:54 AM
May 17

“Machine guns have been illegal in the United States since 1986, a notion that even gun rights groups have come to accept.“



They are legal to own. Do a search on YouTube and you’ll find no shortage of vids showing people firing their privately owned machine guns.

TnDem

(854 posts)
40. re: machine guns
Sat May 17, 2025, 01:29 PM
May 17

Correct, in 1986 the FOPA was passed which essentially banned any new manufacture of transferable class 3 devices, aka "machine guns".

Machine guns that were already in the registry post 1934 and 1937 till 1986 on a form 3 or form 4 are still transferable with a US Treasury tax stamp of $200 per firearm, plus the price of the machinegun.....Which would start around $30,000 each for a pre-86 transferable weapon.

So, yep...If you have $30,000 to $50,000+ laying around for a legal machinegun, then you can buy one once you clear a US Treasury tax stamp.

Kaleva

(39,414 posts)
43. With the proper license, those restrictions don't apply
Sat May 17, 2025, 04:43 PM
May 17

“As an FFL, you can buy a brand new machine gun for less than $2,000 and have it transferred to you in a few days.”

https://rocketffl.com/who-can-own-a-full-auto-machine-gun/

TnDem

(854 posts)
44. Uh, not exactly
Sat May 17, 2025, 04:58 PM
May 17

Incorrect...I didn't read your link, but I already know how it works...it's not that simple at all.

In order to buy a new manufacture or post 86 machinegun or dealer sample, you have to have a Class 3 FFL which is not the standard pawn shop FFL. Also, the post 86 firearm you buy is ONLY transferable to other Class 3 FFL's or as a "dealer sample" for law enforcement agencies....It is NOT transferable to an individual.

The only way an individual can buy a TRANSFERABLE machinegun is to buy it through a Federal C&R FFL, where it has to meet this criteria...."Over 50 years old and/or historically significant"...Even then, the gun has to already be on the registry and/or 1968 amnesty...The cost for C&R machineguns starts at around $25,000 per gun....You are not really paying for the gun as much as you are the privilege to own the gun through the registry.

Kaleva

(39,414 posts)
45. What you are saying doesn't refute what I said
Sat May 17, 2025, 08:24 PM
May 17

I said it’s still legal to own a machine gun and I said that with the proper license, one can buy a new one (post ‘86). Your argument that they aren’t transferable, with the exceptions you listed, doesn’t refute anything I said.

TnDem

(854 posts)
46. Uh, yes it does because they aren't transferable
Sat May 17, 2025, 08:40 PM
May 17

Yes, IF you have a Class 3 FFL dealer, your business/LLC/S-Corp can buy a post-sample for possible LE sales....

No, the class 3 weapon is it not transferable except to a law enforcement agency or another Class 3 dealer....No one can buy a machinegun that is not already on the registry for their own personal collection....PERIOD

Yes, machineguns are available for sale and transfer but they are only available on an ATF Form 3 or Form 4 for a personal collection....Get ready to spend five figures for one.

k_buddy762

(324 posts)
56. Five, six, or even seven figures
Sat May 17, 2025, 11:47 PM
May 17

depending on what you are lookin at.

Class 3 FFLs must pay a Special Operators Tax and are subject to additional scrutiny. Regular (usually annual) inspections by the ATF are conducted, sometimes with little warning to the dealer, and the dealer is expected to abide by the law *to the letter* or he faces prison. Federal regulation of legal machineguns is extremely tight. The ranges, dealers, businesses, etc that maintain an inventory of legal machineguns have been extremely well vetted by the Federal government.

Kaleva

(39,414 posts)
58. You are fixated on the gun being transferable
Sun May 18, 2025, 07:55 AM
May 18

But if you just want the post 1986 gun or guns for yourself, then you can do it by getting the proper license and pay dealer cost.

TnDem

(854 posts)
59. re: Class 3 law
Sun May 18, 2025, 08:18 AM
May 18

That's because you don't want to admit that the only experience you have with this subject is Google and not real life, which is obvious to anyone that knows this subject matter.... I have been involved with this for almost 40 years, so I have a little more experience with it than you do.

As a Class 3 dealer, YOU do not own the gun, the business/LLC/S-Corp owns the gun.... Just because you are holding a Post-86 sample that your company bought for possible sales to a law enforcement agency, it doesn't mean it is your personal gun. If you decide to close your shop, you cannot keep the gun because it belongs to the SOT/FFL, (Special Occupancy Tax holder). If you close your business, then you can then do one of several things....1) Surrender the gun to the BATFE or destroy it, 2) Transfer it to a local LE agency or 3) Sell it to another FFL/SOT as a dealer sample for them to offer an LE agency.

If you buy a TRANSFERABLE Class 3 firearm on the registry as an individual (even if you are a dealer), then you own the gun to do whatever you want with it...Post 86 firearms do not fall in that category.

Bottom line, you, I, Trump or Biden or the Dalai Lama cannot legally personally own a Class 3 firearm personally unless we buy it from the limited 1934-1968 Class 3 weapons that are already on the registry.

There are no more transferables entered into the registry WHATSOEVER,, PERIOD. This is codified in law GCA 1968....A Class 3 firearm is wildly regulated and in a whole other world compared to a simple AR15 that you bought at Rural King for $500.

I am not "fixated" on transferable...That term simply IS the definition of whether or not the gun is even allowed to be owned by anyone. If it isn't transferable, then you don't own it.

Kaleva

(39,414 posts)
60. My father didn't own the small dairy farm he operated
Mon May 19, 2025, 07:47 AM
May 19

It was owned by a corporation of which he had majority shares. Me and my brothers had minority shares. For all practical purposes, my father “owned” the farm even though legally he didn’t as an individual.

When my father passed away, I inherited his shares.

I know how this works.

TnDem

(854 posts)
61. No, you don't
Mon May 19, 2025, 05:10 PM
May 19

If your father was a Class 3 dealer and he passed away, you wouldn't inherit the post 86 Class 3 firearms...No one would without a Class 3 license with SOT.

They would have to be be sold to another Class 3 dealer, police department or turned back in to the BATFE. They are not like a regular AR15, which doesn't even have to be transferred whatsoever.. Your father could literally own hundreds of firearms and none would have to be transferred federally to anyone...Just hand them out at probate.

Class 3 weapons are each on a registry with a certain number and classification and are not transferable period. They are not a "minority share", or a classic Mustang, Glock, AR15 or a Stradivarius.

You just don't understand how it works.

Kaleva

(39,414 posts)
62. But you admit that my father could have owned them?
Tue May 20, 2025, 08:35 AM
May 20

I wouldn’t care if they weren’t transferable to me

TnDem

(854 posts)
65. Can you admit you are wrong?
Tue May 20, 2025, 07:40 PM
May 20

Is always being right whenever you know you're wrong that important?

If you can't sell it, inherit it or claim it, you don't own it....You are either total missing the facts or being intentionally obtuse?

k_buddy762

(324 posts)
64. 3D printed "glock switches"
Tue May 20, 2025, 08:47 AM
May 20

are in every "urban" neighborhood in America. Are you sure you want to bring (totally irrelevant) race into this argument?

Kid Berwyn

(20,486 posts)
52. This is what the Proud Boys standing by have been waiting for.
Sat May 17, 2025, 11:31 PM
May 17

The big round up.

Thanks, Putin.

Norrrm

(1,691 posts)
57. Trump says bump stocks make the gun into a machine gun. Will ban them?
Sun May 18, 2025, 12:23 AM
May 18

Trump says bump stocks make the gun into a machine gun.
https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/department-justice-announces-bump-stock-type-devices-final-rule

Justice Sotomayor Torches Conservative Members of SCOTUS Over Bump Stock Ruling

https://www.democraticunderground.com/100219035760
--------------------------------
https://www.democraticunderground.com/10141997829

"Trump is taking steps toward banning gun bump stocks and strengthening background checks for gun purchasers," it says. "The President has made his intent very clear: 'making our schools and our children safer will be our top priority.'"

Trump will tell any lie, any story, if it will bring him money.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Trump Allows Sale of Devi...